top of page

Shell v Persons Unknown (Terminals) Claim Number : QB-2022-001241

FILTER:

28 October 2024

Continuation Order dated 28 October 2024

22 October 2024

Claimant's Second Authorities Bundle for Hearing on 23 October 2024

21 October 2024

Notice of Final Hearing - 21-22 October 2024

18 October 2024

Eleventh Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 18 October 2024

18 October 2024

Exhibit to Eleventh Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield

16 October 2024

Claimant's Authorities Bundle for Final Hearing listed 21-22 October 2024

16 October 2024

Claimant's Skeleton Argument for Final Hearing listed 21-22 October 2024

16 October 2024

Supplemental Bundle for Final Hearing listed 21-22 October 2024

11 October 2024

Core Bundle for Final Hearing listed 21-22 October 2024

11 October 2024

Miscellaneous Bundle for Final Hearing listed 21-22 October 2024

11 October 2024

Previous Renewal Bundle (Part 1) for Final Hearing listed 21-22 October 2024

11 October 2024

Previous Renewal Bundle (Part 2) for Final Hearing listed 21-22 October 2024

11 October 2024

Previous Renewal Bundle (Part 3) for Final Hearing listed 21-22 October 2024

11 October 2024

Previous Service Bundle for Final Hearing listed 21-22 October 2024

10 October 2024

Draft Final Injunction Order accompanying Sealed Application dated 10 October 2024

Removing the Third Defendant

24 September 2024

Exhibit to Tenth Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield

24 September 2024

Tenth Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 24 September 2024

19 July 2024

Sealed Court Order dated 19 July 2024 - time estimate for Final Hearing

1 July 2024

Exhibit to First Witness Statement of Paul Eilering dated 1 July 2024

1 July 2024

First Witness Statement of Paul Eilering dated 1 July 2024

24 April 2024

High Court Notice of Injunction - Shell Haven

Notice of Injunction granted on 24 April 2024 relating to Shell Haven, Stanford-Le-Hope, Essex

24 April 2024

Sealed Order made by Mr Justice Cotter on 24 April 2024 in relation to the injunction and directions to final hearing - Shell Haven Proceedings

24 April 2024

Sealed Order made by Mr Justice Cotter on 24 April 2024 in relation to the service of future documents - Shell Haven Proceedings

17 April 2024

Approved Judgement following Hearing that took place on 17.04.2024 before Cotter J

17 April 2024

Claimants' skeleton argument for the hearing on 17 April 2024

17 April 2024

Hearing Bundle for Review Hearing listed for 17 April 2024 - PART 1

Hearing Bundle for Review Hearing - 17 April 2024 with a time estimate of 1.5 days - Part 1

17 April 2024

Hearing Bundle for Review Hearing listed for 17 April 2024 - PART 2

Hearing Bundle for Review Hearing - 17 April 2024 with a time estimate of 1.5 days - Part 2

17 April 2024

Summary table of witness evidence in respect of QB-2022-001420, QB-2022-001259 and QB-2022-001241

17 April 2024

Supplemental Bundle for Review Hearing listed for 17 April 2024

Supplemental Bundle for Review Hearing - 17 April 2024 with a time estimate of 1.5 days

17 April 2024

Transcript of Hearing that took place on 17.04.2024 before Cotter J

16 April 2024

Exhibit to Ninth Witness Statement of Alison Judith Oldfield dated 16 April 2024

Exhibit in support of AJO9

16 April 2024

Ninth Witness Statement of Alison Judith Oldfield dated 16 April 2024

AJO9 dealing with service prior to the hearing dated 17 April 2024

11 April 2024

Draft Order made pursuant to the Claimant's application dated 11 April 2024 in respect of QB-2022-001241

Shell Haven - Draft Order made pursuant to the Claimant's application dated 11 April 2024

11 April 2024

Eighth Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 11 April 2024

Eighth Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 11 April 2024 in support of the Claimant's application dated 11 April 2024

11 April 2024

Exhibit to the Eighth Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 11 April 2024

Exhibit in support of the Eighth Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 11 April 2024

11 April 2024

Notice of Hearing dated 11 April 2024

Provides notice of the Review Hearing listed for 17 April 2024 with a time estimate of 1.5 days

11 April 2024

Sealed Application Notice in respect of QB-2022-001241 dated 11 April 2024

11 April 2024

Unsealed Application Notice in respect of QB-2022-001241 dated 11 April 2024

Claimant's application notice dated 11 April 2024 in respect of Shell Haven

15 March 2024

Sealed Court Order dated 15 March 2024

15 March 2024

Transcript for Hearing that took place on 15.03.2024 before Soole J (part heard)

Part heard on 11.03.2024 and part heard on 15.03.2024

14 March 2024

Exhibit to the Fourth Witness Statement of Benjamin Austin dated 14 March 2024

Exhibit in support of the Fourth Witness Statement of Benjamin Austin dated 14 March 2024

14 March 2024

Exhibit to the Second Witness Statement of Christopher Prichard-Gamble dated 14 March 2024

Exhibit in support of the Second Witness Statement of Christopher Prichard-Gamble dated 14 March 2024

14 March 2024

Exhibit to the Seventh Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 14 March 2024

Exhibit in support of the Seventh Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 14 March 2024

14 March 2024

Fourth Witness Statement of Benjamin Austin dated 14 March 2024

14 March 2024

Second Witness Statement of Christopher Prichard-Gamble dated 14 March 2024

14 March 2024

Seventh Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 14 March 2024

Seventh Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield relating to service of the Sealed Court Order dated 13 March 2024

13 March 2024

Sealed Court Order dated 13 March 2024

12 March 2024

Exhibit to the Sixth Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 12 March 2024

Exhibit in support of the Sixth Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 12 March 2024

12 March 2024

Sixth Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 12 March 2024

Sixth Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield relating to service

11 March 2024

Hearing Bundle for Hearing on 11 March 2024

Hearing bundle for the hearing on 11 March 2024 to hear the Claimant's application dated 12 February 2024

11 March 2024

Supplemental Bundle for Hearing on 11 March 2024

Supplemental Bundle to the Bundle for the Hearing on 11 March 2024 containing the Fifth Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 7 March 2024, the Exhibit to the Fifth Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 7 March 2024 and the Claimants' skeleton argument for the hearing on 11 March 2024

11 March 2024

Transcript of Hearing that took place on 11.03.2024 before Soole J (part heard)

Part heard on 11.03.2024 and part heard on 15.03.2024

7 March 2024

Claimant's Skeleton Argument for hearing on 11 March 2024

Relating to joinder, alternative service and directions

7 March 2024

Exhibit to Fifth Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 7 March 2024

7 March 2024

Fifth Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 7 March 2024

29 February 2024

Notice of Hearing dated 29 February 2024

15 February 2024

Sealed Court Order dated 15 February 2024

13 February 2024

Sealed Application Notice dated 13 February 2024

Application seeking permission to add 15 individuals as named defendants to the proceedings, providing directions for trial and granting permission to serve by alternative means

12 February 2024

Draft Order in support of the Claimants' Application dated 12 February 2024

Draft Order accompanying the Claimants' Application dated 12 February 2024

12 February 2024

Exhibit to the Fourth Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 12 February 2024

Exhibit in support of the Fourth Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 12 February 2024

12 February 2024

Fourth Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 12 February 2024

Fourth Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield in support of the Claimants' Application dated 12 February 2024

23 May 2023

Shell Haven - Important Notice - High Court Injunction - 23 May 2023

Shell Haven - Important Notice - High Court Injunction - 23 May 2023

23 May 2023

Shell Haven - Final Injunction Order - dated 23 May 2023

Order made by Mrs Justice Hill - amended under the Slip Rule. Backstop date of 12 May 2024.

2 May 2023

Claimant's further submissions on CPR 40.9 (interested parties) dated 2 May 2023

Dealing with interested party point in CPR 40.9

28 April 2023

Shell Haven Proceedings - Sealed Order dated 28 April 2023 - Injunction to continue until 25 May 2023

Shell Haven Proceedings - Sealed Order dated 28 April 2023 - Injunction to continue until 25 May 2023

26 April 2023

First Witness Statement of Nancy Friel dated 26 April 2023

26 April 2023

Second Witness Statement of Jessica Branch dated 26 April 2023

26 April 2023

Transcript from 26.04.23 - Shell v Persons Unknown Whole Hearing RCJ Kings Bench Division

Transcript of hearing that took place 25 April 2023 – 26 April 2023 before Hill J

25 April 2023

Core and Supplemental Hearing Bundle Index dated April 2023

Bundle index for hearing 25-26 April 2023

25 April 2023

Ms Branch further submissions (Interested party CPR 40.9) dated 25 April 2023

25 April 2023

Transcript from 25.04.23 - Shell v Persons Unknown Whole Hearing RCJ Kings Bench Division

Transcript of hearing that took place 25 April 2023 – 26 April 2023 before Hill J

24 April 2023

First Witness Statement of Jessica Branch dated 24 April 2023

23 April 2023

Skeleton Argument on behalf of Jessica Branch dated 23 April 2023

20 April 2023

Claimant's Skeleton Argument dated 20 April 2023 for hearing on 25-26 April 2023

20 April 2023

Claimant’s Skeleton Argument dated 20 April 2023

Skeleton Argument for hearing 25-26 April 2023

20 April 2023

Shell Haven Proceedings - Draft Order requesting that the Shell Haven Injunction Order shall continue to operate until 25 May 2023 unless varied, discharged or extended by further order, whichever is sooner.

Shell Haven Proceedings - Draft Order requesting that the Shell Haven Injunction Order shall continue to operate until 25 May 2023 unless varied, discharged or extended by further order, whichever is sooner.

20 April 2023

Shell Haven Proceedings - Draft Order sought pursuant to the Claimant's application dated 30 March 2023

Shell Have Proceedings - Draft Order sought pursuant to the Claimant's application dated 30 March 2023 - seeking that the Shell Haven Injunction Order shall continue to operate until trial or further order or with a backstop of 23:59 [on the anniversary of one calendar year from the date of this order] (“the backstop date”), unless varied, discharged or extended by further order, whichever is sooner.

20 April 2023

Shell Haven, Shell Tower and Petrol Station Proceedings - CLAIMANTS’ SKELETON ARGUMENT ahead of Hearing on 25-26 April 2023 - dated 20 April 2023

Shell Haven, Shell Tower and Petrol Station Proceedings - CLAIMANTS’ SKELETON ARGUMENT ahead of Hearing on 25-26 April 2023 - dated 20 April 2023

19 April 2023

Part 1 of the Exhibit to the Second Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 19 April 2023 in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre and Petrol Station Proceedings

AJO2 Part 1 - Exhibit to the Second Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 19 April 2023 in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations injunction renewal applications

19 April 2023

Part 2 of the Exhibit to the Second Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 19 April 2023 in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre and Petrol Station Proceedings

AJO2 Part 2 - Exhibit to the Second Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 19 April 2023 in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations injunction renewal applications

19 April 2023

Part 3 of the Exhibit to the Second Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 19 April 2023 in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre and Petrol Station Proceedings

AJO2 Part 3 - Exhibit to the Second Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 19 April 2023 in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations injunction renewal applications

19 April 2023

Part 4 of the Exhibit to the Second Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 19 April 2023 in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre and Petrol Station Proceedings

AJO2 Part 4 - Exhibit to the Second Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 19 April 2023 in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations injunction renewal applications

19 April 2023

Part 5 of the Exhibit to the Second Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 19 April 2023 in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre and Petrol Station Proceedings

AJO2 Part 5 - Exhibit to the Second Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 19 April 2023 in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations injunction renewal applications

19 April 2023

Part 6 of the Exhibit to the Second Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 19 April 2023 in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre and Petrol Station Proceedings

AJO2 Part 6 - Exhibit to the Second Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 19 April 2023 in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations injunction renewal applications

19 April 2023

Second Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 19 April 2023 in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre and Petrol Station Proceedings

Second Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations injunction renewal applications

30 March 2023

Exhibit to Fay Lashbrook's Witness Statement dated 30 March 2023 in support of Shell Haven injunction renewal application

FL1 - Exhibit to Fay Lashbrook's Witness Statement dated 30 March 2023 in support of Shell Haven injunction renewal application

30 March 2023

First Witness Statement of Chris Gamble in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations injunction renewal applications

First Witness Statement of Chris Gamble in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations injunction renewal applications

30 March 2023

First Witness Statement of Fay Lashbrook in support of Shell Haven injunction renewal application

Witness Statement in support of Shell Haven injunction renewal application

30 March 2023

Part 1 of the Exhibit to Chris Gamble’s First Witness Statement in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations injunction renewal applications

CPG1 Part 1 - Exhibit to the First Witness Statement of Chris Gamble dated 30 March 2023 in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations injunction renewal application

30 March 2023

Part 2 of the Exhibit to Chris Gamble’s First Witness Statement in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations injunction renewal applications

CPG1 Part 2 - Exhibit to the First Witness Statement of Chris Gamble dated 30 March 2023 in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations injunction renewal applications

30 March 2023

Part 3 of the Exhibit to Chris Gamble’s First Witness Statement in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations injunction renewal applications

CPG1 Part 3 - Exhibit to the First Witness Statement of Chris Gamble 30 March 2023 in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations injunction renewal applications - PART 3

30 March 2023

Part 4 of the Exhibit to Chris Gamble’s First Witness Statement in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations injunction renewal applications

CPG1 Part 4 - Exhibit to the First Witness Statement of Chris Gamble dated 30 March 2023 in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations injunction renewal applications

30 March 2023

Part 5 of the Exhibit to Chris Gamble’s First Witness Statement in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations injunction renewal applications

CPG1 Part 5 - Exhibit to the First Witness Statement of Chris Gamble dated 30 March 2023 in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations injunction renewal applications - PART 5

30 March 2023

Shell Haven Proceedings – Claimant’s Sealed Application dated 30 March 2023

Application seeking an extension of the injunction granted by the order dated 3 May 2022 and permission for alternative service

29 March 2023

Exhibit to the First Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations Proceedings

AJO1 - Exhibit to the First Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations injunction renewal applications

29 March 2023

First Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 29 March 2023 in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations Proceedings

First Witness Statement of Alison Oldfield dated 29 March 2023 in support of Shell Haven, Shell Centre Tower and Shell Petrol Stations injunction renewal applications

13 March 2023

Letter from Court dated 13 March 2023 - Notice of Hearing for 25 April 2023 in respect of Shell Centre Tower, Shell Haven and Shell Petrol Station Proceedings

Letter of notice of application hearing on 25 April 2023

28 February 2023

Order dated 28 February 2023 to confirm combined hearing for all 3 proceedings made in respect of Shell Centre Tower, Shell Haven and Shell Petrol Station Proceedings

Order to grant permission for the review hearing in these three proceedings to be listed and heard at the same time

27 February 2023

Shell Haven, Shell Centre and Petrol Station Proceedings - Claimant’s Application dated 27 February 2023

Application requesting that the review hearing for the 3 proceedings are listed and heard together

27 February 2023

Shell Haven, Shell Centre and Petrol Station Proceedings - Draft Order as appended to Claimant's Application dated 27 February 2023

Appended to Claimant's Application dated 27 February 2023

23 February 2023

Shell Haven Proceedings - Certificate of Service confirming service of Form N434 (Notification that Eversheds are now instructed) on CMS

Service of Form N434 (Notice of Change of Legal Representative) on CMS

23 February 2023

Shell Haven Proceedings - Certificate of Service confirming service of Form N434 (Notification that Eversheds are now instructed) on Defendants

Service of Form N434 (Notice of Change of Legal Representative) on Defendants

14 February 2023

Shell Haven Proceedings - Notice of Acting dated 14 February 2023

Confirmation that Eversheds Sutherland (International) LLP is now acting for Claimant

3 May 2022

Shell Haven Proceedings - Sealed Order dated 3 May 2022

Final Injunction Order

28 April 2022

Shell Haven and Shell Centre Tower Proceedings - Attendance Note - Hearing on 28 April 2022

Hearing before Mr Justice Bennathan on 28 April 2022

28 April 2022

Transcript of Bennathan J Judgement from hearing on 28 April 2022 (Haven and Tower)

27 April 2022

Ms Branch Skeleton Argument dated 27 April 2022 (Tower and Haven)

Objections to interim injunctions granted on 15 and 15 April 2022

22 April 2022

Exhibit to Second Witness Statement of Stephen Ian Brown dated 22 April 2022 in support of the Shell Haven injunction renewal application

SIB2 - Exhibit to Second Witness Statement of Stephen Ian Brown dated 22 April 2022 in support of the Shell Haven injunction renewal application

22 April 2022

Exhibit to the Second Witness Statement of Emma Margaretha Florence Pinkerton dated 22 April 2022 made in support of the Shell Haven proceedings

EMPI2 - Exhibit to Second Witness Statement of Emma Margaretha Florence Pinkerton dated 22 April 2022 in support of the Shell Haven proceedings

22 April 2022

Second Witness Statement of Emma Margaretha Florence Pinkerton dated 22 April 2022 in support of the Shell Haven Proceedings

Second Witness Statement in support of the Shell Haven Proceedings

22 April 2022

Second Witness Statement of Stephen Ian Brown dated 22 April 2022 in support of the Shell Haven Proceedings

Second Witness Statement of Stephen Ian Brown dated 22 April 2022 in support of the Shell Haven Proceedings

22 April 2022

Shell Haven Proceedings - Appendix to Certificate of Service

Originally filed by CMS

22 April 2022

Shell Haven Proceedings - Certificate of Service dated 22 April 2022

Served on 15 April 2022, deemed service is 21 April 2022.

This certificate confirms delivery of 1. Claim Form, 2. Particulars of Claim, 3. Particulars of Claim - exhibit bundle, 4. Application Notice, 5. Order relating to Shell Haven (dated 14 April 2022), 6. Order - Appendix 1, 7. Order (dated 15 April 2022 - relating to permission to amend Claim Form, Particulars of Claim and Application Notice), 8. Order relating to Kingsbury Terminal, 9. Witness Statement of Emma Pinkerton, 10. Exhibit bundle EMPI1, 11. Witness statement of Stephen Ian Brown, 12. Exhibit bundle of SBI1 and 13. Response pack

22 April 2022

Shell Haven Proceedings - Draft Order - Undated 2022

Draft Final Injunction Order

22 April 2022

Shell Haven Proceedings - Sealed Application Notice dated 22 April 2022

Application seeking permission to continue injunctive relief granted under an order dated 14 April 2022

15 April 2022

Shell Haven Proceedings - Amended Application dated 14 April 2022 (amends made on 15 April 2022 and shown in red)

Amended application seeking permission to amend granted by order made by Mr Justice Sweeting on 15 April 2022

15 April 2022

Shell Haven Proceedings - Amended Claim Form dated 14 April 2022 (amends shown in red)

Permission to amend granted by Mr Justice Sweeting on 15 April 2022

In this Claim Form, the Claimant seeks injunctions to restrain trespass and nuisance to its sites at Shell Haven, Stanford-le-Hope, Essex, and Kingsbury Terminal, Kingsbury, Warwickshire

15 April 2022

Shell Haven Proceedings - Amended Particulars of Claim dated 14 April 2022 (amends made on 15 April 2022 and shown in red)

Permission to amend granted by Mr Justice Sweeting on 15 April 2022

15 April 2022

Shell Haven Proceedings - Order by Mr Justice Sweeting dated 15 April 2022 granting permission to amend pleadings

Permission to amend pleadings

14 April 2022

Claimant's Skeleton Argument dated 14 April 2022 (interim injunction)

14 April 2022

Exhibit to the First Witness Statement of Emma Pinkerton dated 14 April 2022 in support of Shell Haven Proceedings

EMPI1 - Exhibit to the First Witness Statement of Emma Pinkerton dated 14 April 2022 in support of Shell Haven Proceedings

14 April 2022

First Witness Statement of Emma Pinkerton dated 14 April 2022 in support of Shell Haven Proceedings

First Witness Statement of Emma Pinkerton in support of Shell Haven Proceedings

14 April 2022

Shell Haven Proceedings - Attendance Note - Hearing on 14 April 2022

Hearing (remote) before Mr Justice Sweeting, 14 April 2022, starting at 15:42

14 April 2022

Shell Haven Proceedings - Exhibit to the Particulars of Claim dated 14 April 2022

Linked to the Particulars of Claim dated 14 April 2022 made in support of the Shell Haven Proceedings

14 April 2022

Shell Haven Proceedings - Order by Mr Justice Sweeting - Undated 2022

Order adjourning the Claimants Application in relation to the Claimants’ terminal at Kingsbury

14 April 2022

Shell Haven Proceedings - Order by Mr Justice Sweeting dated 14 April 2022

Interim Injunction

13 April 2022

Exhibit to First Witness Statement of Stephen Ian Brown dated 13 April 2022 in support of the Shell Haven Proceedings - Exhibit SIB1

SIB1 - Exhibit to First Witness Statement of Stephen Ian Brown dated 13 April 2022 in support of the Shell Haven Proceedings

13 April 2022

First Witness Statement of Stephen Ian Brown dated 13 April 2022

First Witness Statement of Stephen Ian Brown dated 13 April 2022 in support of the Shell Haven injunction application

Shell Centre Tower, Shell Haven and Petrol Station Proceedings - Draft Order requested as part of the Claimant's Application Notice dated 14 February 2023 - Undated 2023

Draft Order Requesting a Combined Hearing for the 3 claims

Shell Haven Proceedings - Draft Order requesting extension of injunction - Undated 2023

Draft Order in relation to the Shell Haven injunction

Shell Haven Proceedings - N9 Response Pack - Undated 2022

N9 Response Pack

Shell Haven Proceedings - Revised 3B Order - Appendix 1 - Undated 2022

Appendix of plans

Shell Haven Proceedings – Final Draft Order requesting extension of injunction - Undated 2023

Final Draft Order seeking permission to continue the injunction and for alternative service

bottom of page